16 June, 2010
Independent Jewish Voices – Canada condemns what it calls a “feeding frenzy” around NDP Member of Parliament Libby Davies.
“What’s next?”asked IJV-C spokesperson Larry Haiven. “Will Canadian politicians have to take a loyalty oath to the State of Israel in order to hold office? The feeding frenzy is outrageous. Libby Davies is one the bravest and most honest politicians in Canada. She has done more for a just peace between Israelis and Palestinians than any other Canadian politician. ”
Members of the Conservative, Liberal and even her own New Democratic Party have rushed to denounce Davies as “anti-Israel” for remarks she made on video to an internet journalist and some have called for her to be expelled from her caucus. Ms. Davies has apologized for and clarified some of her remarks but the hysteria continues. “In fact the story is no longer what Libby Davis said but the mania surrounding it,” said Haiven, “It is a distraction from more pressing issues like the Israeli attack on the Gaza flotilla.”
“The central remark causing the uproar was that Israel had been occupying Palestinian territory since 1948. This is factually correct. In the 1948 Israeli War of Independence (known to the Palestinians as the ‘Nakba’) more than 750,000 Palestinians were forced to leave what later became the State of Israel. They have never been allowed to return. Much of the land that these people left had been designated by the United Nations Partition Plan of 1947 as Palestinian territory,” Haiven explained.
But pointing out this fact is not tantamount to denying Israel’s right to exist. Says Haiven, “Historians (including Israeli scholars like Benny Morris), governments and individuals all over the world acknowledge that Israel seized Palestinian territory in 1948 (and again in 1967) and expelled the Palestinian residents. Nevertheless, the prevailing consensus is that Israel has the right to exist within the territory it was occupying at the end of its War of Independence (the so-called ‘Green Line’.) Even the PLO has conceded this point.”
“We condemn all those who would pillory Ms. Davies,” said Haiven, “But we are particularly disappointed with NDP leader Jack Layton and NDP MP Thomas Mulcair. The NDP should stop this nonsense and address the underlying issues that are at the root of the continuing crisis in Israel and Palestine.”
Independent Jewish Voices – Canada is a national organization whose mandate is to promote a just resolution to the conflict in Israel and Palestine through the application of international law and respect for the human rights of all parties. IJV has chapters in Halifax, Montreal, Ottawa, Toronto, Hamilton, Winnipeg, Saskatoon and Vancouver plus many individual members.
–
Larry Haiven, Spokesperson, Independent Jewish Voices Canada
This woman does more for my neighborhood than anyone in municipal, provincial or federal government put together. As a Jewish man I think it is absolutely deplorable the way we are treating this woman…in fact I would go so far as to say it makes me sick. Libby is a shining beacon of hope for us who feel neglected and betrayed by government and it is about time that us Jews stop blindly attacking anyone who says anything remotely negative about Israel.
Just found this site and so far from what I see I would like to thank you………….we need more brave voices such as yours
Thank you for taking this position in support of Libby Davies, and confirming the factual correctness of her comment
I respect your courage and the fact that you are aknowledging the all the true facts.I praise you..Israel has the right to exist but not like this..enough is enough i agree totally.Its like you cannot say anything or your labeled anti semetic.Its not about liking or hating Jewish people or their right to exist is all about the Israeli goverment policies and the way they are conducting themselves.No other goverment could get away with the tactics they use. Again i praise you and long live the truth.
Well, in view of Layton’s cowardice on this issue, it looks like I’ll be voting Green again–if and when we ever get an election. That’s twice in a row after a long lifetime of voting exclusively NDP. I admire Libby Davis; maybe she should start her own party.
Bravo!
So glad you’ve issued this statement.
You bring a note of sanity and fairness to the Israel/Palestine territorial dispute. Perhaps you could remind the reader that you favour a two-state solution.
Thank you.